Of course. After reviewing their 2024 seasons, the clear and consensus answer is that Jannik Sinner had a definitively better season than Carlos Alcaraz.
While Alcaraz had monumental, career-defining highs, Sinner’s season was characterized by unparalleled consistency, a meteoric rise to the world’s top ranking, and a superior head-to-head record.
Here is a detailed breakdown of their 2024 seasons to support this conclusion:
Jannik Sinner’s Season: Consistency and Dominance
Sinner’s 2024 campaign was a masterpiece of sustained excellence.
-
Grand Slam Performance: He captured his first major title at the Australian Open, a career-defining achievement. He followed this up with a semi-final at the French Open and a semi-final at Wimbledon, showing remarkable prowess on all surfaces.
-
Masters 1000 Success: He won the Miami Open and reached the final of the Monte-Carlo Masters and the Indian Wells Masters, where he lost to Alcaraz.
-
World No. 1: His consistent results propelled him to the ATP World No. 1 ranking for the first time in his career in June, a testament to his year-long dominance.
-
Win/Loss Record: He boasted an incredible 78-14 match record for the year.
-
Head-to-Head: Sinner held a 4-2 advantage over Alcaraz in 2024, including a pivotal win in the French Open semi-finals.
Sinner’s Key 2024 Titles:
-
Australian Open (Grand Slam)
-
Miami Open (Masters 1000)
-
Rotterdam (ATP 500)
-
Vienna (ATP 500)
Carlos Alcaraz’s Season: The King of the Biggest Stages
Alcaraz’s season was defined by spectacular peaks, including defending a major title, but was marred by more inconsistency and injury disruptions.
-
Grand Slam Performance: He successfully defended his Wimbledon title, defeating Novak Djokovic in a stunning straight-sets final. This was his third major. However, he was upset early at the Australian Open (QF) and the US Open (4th Round), and lost to Sinner in the French Open semi-finals.
-
Masters 1000 Success: He won a historic Indian Wells Masters, but did not win another Masters title during the year.
-
Inconsistency and Injury: Alcaraz’s season was punctuated by more erratic results and physical issues that affected his rhythm, including an arm problem that forced him to miss the Italian Open and impacted his French Open preparation.
-
Win/Loss Record: He had a very strong, but less dominant, 67-13 record.
Alcaraz’s Key 2024 Titles:
-
Wimbledon (Grand Slam)
-
Indian Wells (Masters 1000)
-
Roland Garros (Grand Slam)
Head-to-Head Comparison & Verdict
| Category | Jannik Sinner | Carlos Alcaraz | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grand Slams | 1 Title, 2 SF | 1 Title, 1 SF | Sinner (More consistent) |
| Masters 1000 | 1 Title, 2 F | 1 Title | Sinner |
| Year-End No. 1 | Yes | No | Sinner |
| Win/Loss Record | 78-14 (84.8%) | 67-13 (83.8%) | Sinner |
| H2H in 2024 | 4-2 | 2-4 | Sinner |
| Biggest Achievement | First Slam, Reached No. 1 | Defended Wimbledon Title | Debatable, but Sinner’s was rarer |
Conclusion:
While Carlos Alcaraz won what many consider the most prestigious tournament (Wimbledon) and played an unforgettable level of tennis to do so, Jannik Sinner was the better player over the entirety of the 2024 season.
Sinner’s ability to perform at an elite level week-in and week-out, across all surfaces, his ascent to the World No. 1 ranking, and his dominant head-to-head record against his rival give him the edge. Alcaraz’s season was fantastic, but Sinner’s was historically great and the best of any male player in 2024.
Shop with us
CR7 – Cristiano Ronaldo #7 T-shirt
Original price was: $28.00.$23.00Current price is: $23.00.Jannik Sinner Custom Tennis T-shirt
Original price was: $28.00.$23.00Current price is: $23.00.
